Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] If you don't know your numbers, you don't know your business. 0:17 I learned this the hard way with my first company, so I created NetSuite, the world's number one cloud business system. 0:24 NetSuite gives you the visibility and control you need to make smart decisions and grow with confidence. That's why companies who use NetSuite grow three times faster than the S&P 500. 0:37 Schedule your free product tour right now. Hello, everyone, and welcome to the Digital Leader Show. 0:53 We're live each Wednesday at noon Eastern, 9:00 Pacific, talking key issues in news at the intersection of business and technology, with a special focus on automation, AI, and digital transformation in hopes of making you a better digital leader. 1:06 Today we're discussing the changing search, is it good? How AI is changing search for good, plus headlines for digital leaders. Thanks to our sponsor, Oracle NetSuite. 1:16 Their unified cloud business management platform helps organizations automate core processes and provide real-time visibility into operational and financial performance. 1:26 ERPA AI members and followers can receive special pricing and resources at erpaai.com/netsuite. I'm Dan Goodstein. I head up ERPA AI and the Digital Enterprise Institute. 1:36 We're a professional association me- media and peer-to-peer research network providing education, networking, advice to over 130,000 members globally all around automation, enterprise AI, and digital transformation. 1:49 My co-host is Carlos Alvarenga, a researcher, author, and coach. He currently serves as chair of our new technology innovation board, and he was previously senior research fellow and professor at the Robert H. 2:00 School of Business, University of Maryland, and held leadership roles at World 50 Labs, EY, and Accenture. Good afternoon, Carlos. Great. Good afternoon. Great to be back again for another show with you. 2:12 My pleasure to have you and, uh, do this with you. And, uh, sorry for the late start, had some, uh, technical glitches of my own, but hey, that's part of being a digital leader, right? That's right, Dan. 2:22 So you work through it and push through. That's what's impressive. You work through it, yeah. We've had, uh, we've had a lot of, lot of news. 2:28 And you know what's funny is, um, you know, before we decided, um, uh, before we saw the news out of Google this week from their, their conference, we actually picked the topic for today's show, ended up being, uh, very appropriate. 2:41 So we're gonna talk about, uh, that in, in, in a bit. But, uh, lots in the headlines. I had a couple that I wanted to get your opinions on- Sure... Carlos. 2:50 Uh, you know, o- one of which was that a, a survey came out from, uh, our friends over at KPMG, uh, saying that 100% of US financial reporting leaders say they have a plan to either pilot or implement AI in financial reporting in the next three years. 3:08 100%, not 90, 70, 60. I think it was 70% when they did it a couple years ago. Well, the, the problem is you can't be the one who says they don't, right? [laughs] So... 3:20 Will they actually do it is the, is the better question. Oh, and that's, hey, like why are you the one person [laughs] who doesn't care about AI in, in accounting? [laughs] Yeah, exactly. 3:30 That's a call nobody wants to get over at KPMG, [laughs] so, or at least the clients don't. But the, the, the point is well taken, right? 3:36 Certainly we, you know, we talked with The Knot last week about AI in creative industries. Uh, I, I would imagine this is a big issue with, with financial reporting, with auditing, right? 3:47 A- as we know, anybody who, who has spent time in the audit world or audit firm knows that there's always this, I don't wanna use like, what is it? 3:55 Like kind, you know, a mutually agreed upon fiction, but there's, there's something to that in any financial statement, as fraud after fraud says, right? 4:02 The, the auditor will always put there's a whole bunch of disclaimers at the bottom, and this is only as good as what we were told. Yeah. Everybody understands that. It's, it's still something that has to be done. 4:11 So we'll see, right? What is AI, what i- what will be the impact of AI on accounting and on auditing and on financial statements? 4:19 Uh, I remember reading a couple years back a paper that a professor, I think it was at Chicago, had written where 4:27 he and his team had looked at, um, certain keywords in the risk sections of financial reporting, and they said, look, if, if you, if you look at the key... And this is using sort of early stage r- language models. 4:40 These are very good indicators of problems in these firms oc- you know, occurring publicly within the next six to 12 months. And this is a, a very early stage research project. I would imagine by now it's even stronger. 4:51 So I think we'll see two things, right? 4:53 One is the use of ho- maybe the use of that to improve auditing and to improve risk, uh, um, reporting and detection, but then also people analyzing perhaps these statements in ways, you know, 10-Ks and everything else in ways that haven't been analyzed in the past and, and at scale. 5:10 So yeah, I, it seems like an esoteric topic, but I, but I don't think that it is. I think it, it could have significant implications for governance and management w- within a relatively short period of time. 5:22 Also in the news, uh, AWS's, uh, CEO is stepping down, and, uh, you know, it's been a, it's been a interesting few years for, for AWS. 5:32 They've had some, uh, deceleration in revenue growth as they, as the financial guys like to say. Right. Um, uh, blamed it on raise, rising interest rates and things. 5:42 But, you know, net, net, they, you know, had a couple rounds of layoffs, uh, over the last year, uh, 27,000 employees being let go. 5:52 Um, and somebody told, uh, CNBC that the, the new, the incoming CEO, uh, this guy Matt Garman, is, uh, kind of a, a wartime CEO in the sense- Uh, he may, uh, it may indicate that they're looking to shake some things up around, uh, uh, AI. 6:10 They lost some market share, I think, to Microsoft over the last year. Uh, so, uh, interesting, interesting there. We talked about them from the standpoint of, uh, you know, AI, uh, recently. 6:20 I'm not familiar with, with this particular case. I, I, I do b- I do know that the CEO of Amazon, Andy Jassy, was formerly CEO of, of AWS, right? So as you know, just generally speaking, it's hard to follow 6:32 when you take over the job of the person who becomes CEO. Uh, there's always maybe a little... 6:37 Well, not always, but perhaps there's a little bit of extra pressure or scrutiny on that if, if you become head of sales and because that, the former head of sales become CEO, then there's always... 6:45 I, I know people have d- who have done that. Right. And they, they sense a little bit higher pressure because it's a job the CEO had in the past and was so good at it that became CEO through the job. 6:55 So, um, yeah, I, I don't- I wonder if there may be somewhere in the back room there's a little bit of that. It's a tough, you know, big shoes to fill maybe at Amazon. Mm-hmm. 7:04 But then maybe also, like we talked before many times, right? 7:06 The broader issue of AI transforming lots of different things and, and maybe what we're seeing, this is an indication of shifts that are happening structurally within cloud that, um, 7:18 that may be related to that, what's happening in the broader sense of with technology as a whole, right? But yeah, I don't know, but you may, you may be following this story a little bit more closely than I am. 7:25 No, I had. I just thought the timing was very interesting. You know, we- Yeah... 7:28 we talked about some of the, uh, cloud providers, uh, it was last week or a couple weeks back in our headlines about just the, the revenue growth they've seen on the, on the coattails of, of AI and the, the ne- the need for, for, you know, computing power. 7:43 So I thought the timing of this was interesting. Of course, you know, they said it was for family reasons and, and all that, but, uh, uh, most people don't believe that. 7:50 So, uh, so that, that was just kind of interesting. 7:53 The, the other, uh, thing before we get into some of the, the Google announcements from its annual I/O developer conference, which started yesterday, um, you know, I think we've, you and I have talked about this topic in the past, driverless cars seem like they're on the, on the regulatory, uh, hot seat right now. 8:09 Mm-hmm. Uh, speaking of Google Alphabet, uh, Waymo is, uh, the latest car company to get a, a pro federal investigation, uh, based on, uh, 22 incidents, uh, involving its, its robotaxis. GM has been in the news. 8:26 Obviously, Tesla's been in the news, um, uh, whether they've kind of misled people about their- Yeah... autopilot function. 8:33 So, uh, it seems like it might be a, uh, a, a, um, a pivot point or a turning point for this, this space. 8:42 Well, this is what's gonna be, right, one of the, one of the great technical challenges of our time, and I have followed the, the Tesla case and, and- Yeah... 8:48 and the lawsuits and the deaths and people who were killed right on the side of the road and all kinds of things, crashes. Um, sometimes it seems to me, again, right, allegedly, I'll say that, right? 8:59 [laughs] Either sometimes the tech, but also sometimes the driver, people who, who are, who don't observe what it is that they're supposed to be doing, uh, because they are for whatever reason. 9:08 But it just, the complexity of the issue, right, is, is still a remarkable thing, and yeah, this is just one of those challenges that steps forward, right? 9:19 Not to step back, and, um, unfortunately, at least if you look at the articles that I've read, people are dying, right? At a, you know, in a, in not, in a significant number as, as kind of unintended casualties, right? 9:34 Or un- some, you know, rec- nobody volunteered to be part of Tesla's AI experiment or self-driving experiment, but my car just got destroyed and somebody gets killed. 9:43 I'm, I'm part of Tesla's innovation curve and, and I think the comments by Mr. Musk was something like, "Well, this is just innovation is hard." Right? Well, that's, that's great. 9:52 [laughs] It's really hard if you're dead because- Coming from the guy who wants to send people to Mars, right? Well, yeah. So obviously it needs to be under- Well, right... 9:58 10 level scrutiny You're not, right, you didn't get hit by the, on the side of the road by a runaway Tesla. Yeah. So [laughs] Yeah, yeah. 10:04 You know, the, again, we- we- we actually said this in one of our shows a while back where- Yeah... 10:08 and I think I said something to the effect of, there are gonna be people who are gonna get killed by autonomous vehicles who are just lab ex- lab rats, right? 10:17 They're, they're part of this culture of, well, a few bodies piled up along the way is a small price to pay for us to have self-driving cars in 2035- [laughs]... or whatever the day is. Mm-hmm. 10:28 Well, you know, I think, and we've talked about this maybe, maybe a year ago back, right? I, I, you know, I, I think it's, you know, some, some of these AI conversations are unfair in a vacuum though, right? 10:38 I, you know, and certainly I'm not, I'm not condoning [laughs] the loss of life for the advancement of innovation. But, you know, I, I think to have the conversation in a vacuum is, is, is difficult. 10:48 You have to compare it to the current state. We've talked about AI and customer service, right? So, you know, is, is it, is it a better or worse experience, you know, dealing with an AI versus a, a human? 10:59 It can't just be is AI good or bad, it's gotta be- Yeah. No... you know, is it a better experience? If, I don't think it is in a vacuum. 11:04 If you, if you, if you read the story that says, Tesla's car got confused because it was foggy, or is, remember the one it was sunny, it didn't like sunlight [laughs] so, right? 11:14 And because- Problematic in California, right? Right. Exactly. [laughs] This Tesla didn't like sunlight, so it rammed into somebody who was stick- who was changing a flat tire. Like, that's not in a vacuum. 11:24 That is the car. No, I just mean though, compare... So comp- what, what do you compare it to? So, you know, you compare it to human error. If a human was driving that car, would the human have avoided that, right? 11:35 There'd be the stats around car safety or cr- I mean, it's, it's amazing people don't get- Yeah. Fair enough... look at those stats. 11:40 But to your point, right, you know, maybe we say, "Hey, this is still safer than, you know, grandma driving, who probably needs to get her eyes checked again, and there was no need for her to get her license renewed at 75 years old." 11:54 But, you know, GM has this lawsuit where the GM Cruise not only, you know, knocked over a pedestrian, but dragged them 20 feet, right? I don't think a human would've... 12:04 Hopefully, [laughs] a human wouldn't have done that. A human would've noticed, like I did the other day when I ran over, like, some kid's bike ramp. Like, that doesn't sound right. I have something going on. 12:13 I need to stop my car immediately and see what's underneath my car, right? No, you're right. That's fair enough. And, and, and, you know, touche, right? That if, if, if that, that's the thing about context, you're right. 12:22 It maybe it's possible that even with the Teslas that don't like sunlight, at the end of the day, a Tesla on its own is way safer than the, quote-unquote, "average"- I don't know. Yeah. I don't know... I don't know. 12:33 I, I don't know what that story- That doesn't seem that way, but I could be wrong, right? This is like, this is like, uh... No, uh, people be up in the news. Boeing- Yeah... who's also in the news these days, right? 12:44 Okay. Safety concerns, whatever, but it's still, like, in, you know, way safer to fly even with, with, quote-unquote, "Boeing's issues." Yes, without a doubt, right? 12:53 So that, but the problem is that when something goes wrong, it goes wrong in a spectacular way. 12:58 Maybe we're seeing that a little bit in these stories about Tesla, that if you- No one reports the fact that somebody just crashed because it just crashed, right? 13:06 The, but if a Tesla crashes, then yeah, there's a lot of noise about that. So it could be that's the case, right? 13:10 Well, and, and what's scary, you know, what's scary, the most scary part of the Boeing, w- since you brought it up, the, the Boeing, you know, news, at least the, the news I've seen, you know, is the cover-up factor. 13:22 The, the push by, by leadership allegedly, you know, a push- Right... by leadership to, to sh- uh, to short-circuit, if I can use that word, some of the safety, uh, testing and to push things that maybe weren't safe. 13:37 Uh, and then to hide the fact that... 'Cause you go, you go on an airplane, you know, assuming a certain level of risk- Right... just like you go in a car assuming a certain level of risk. 13:47 And, and you know, that Tesla lawsuit, at least the one that I, that I referenced before, is not even about the safety of the car necessarily. 13:54 It's about whether or not they misled drivers and investors into thinking that the autopilot was fully, you know, self-driving. 14:01 So it gets back to, and we, I think we talked maybe eight or nine months back when we talked about this last, about, you know, the cameras that are on the Tesla recording as you walk by, right? Right. 14:09 So did you opt into that [laughs] as a pedestrian walking past the c- Right? 14:13 So I think it's about the, and we've talked about this a million times on this show, about the transparency behind some of these things, and then you make your own, you know, assessments of, of risk as a person, right? 14:26 You're right, and it's, it can, as, as technology progresses, right, we s- we see the intrusiveness again, right, progress with it, and in many cases, the pushback against it. 14:36 And so yeah, it's just the, the nature of the world in which we're in today, that we're constantly being monitored, surveyed, by ring cameras that are sort of ubiquitous in, in many places. 14:47 That becomes the, you know, one other thing you can sort of point to. But yeah, we're, we're in this, uh, world of being seen and monitored, and 14:55 as, we always talk about this, right, in levels that are way more than, than we even imagine on a daily basis. So, um, 15:04 Google kicked off its, uh, annual IO developer conference, and maybe I should've known this, but I didn't know that, uh, Search was gonna be such a big part of it, so I wanna get into that. 15:12 Obviously, it's our, our main topic here. But a couple other announcements, uh, that, that came out of, uh, that so far. I think it's still going on. Mm-hmm. 15:20 But, um, you know, there's this, uh, Gemini Nano, uh, which is Google's on-device, uh, large language model for devices, uh, mobile devices. 15:31 Um, they're infusing AI into its workplace suite of office tools, so that's gonna rival, you know, Microsoft with OpenAI's, uh, um, uh, ChatGPT tools that are built into Microsoft Office Suite. 15:45 Um, uh, we're gonna talk about, uh, uh, Search, but they, they announced some, some pretty big evolutions in the, uh, the world of, of Search, uh, privacy and, and, and some of those things and, and kinda what they're kinda calling AI-organized search, which allows for kinda more tightly presented and readable search results, as the ability to get responses from longer queries and searches with photos and, uh, and things like that. 16:11 And that's launching this week. So, uh, lot, lotta, lotta interesting updates from Google, which... Little bit behind the eight ball in this area, right? 16:23 Well, I, and before we get into this, right, there's also the interesting story of Google in the news because of Project Nimbus this week. Right. Did I lose you? Now can you... I assume you can hear me now, Dan. 16:37 Lost Carlos. Can you hear me, Dan? 17:56 Sorry, everybody. Lost my, uh, lost my internet connection. Don't know what happened there. No worries. I- Carlos. I was on a rant, so that's the problem. I was- [laughs] You overloaded. 18:07 You o- [laughs] You broke, you broke the internet. [laughs] I broke the internet. It's your anti-Google rant. Hey, listen. Uh, what I was mentioning was the, the issue of Project Nimbus, right, in the headlines. 18:16 'Cause like this is, it's not a search issue, but it is Google, and I was, before- In researching for the, for this week's show, I happened to come across an article from Insight Partners about search, but also I came across the statement that CEO made in res- 18:30 you know, a while back saying, "Hey, we're about to enter this new age of AI. The one thing we don't want is people using the company as this is a business. 18:40 So keep your personal stuff kind of out of Google and your protests." And of course, some people were not happy with that. 18:45 And we go back to this thing we've talked about in the past of social issues, right, and social pressures moving into crossing into corporate spaces, and 18:56 that continues to be yet another thing, right, that defines ev- And as we go through this, and I would imagine, right, this in today's talk, but at some point it's worth a conversation about how 19:05 as, as AI continues to develop, it- I think it's also gonna bring new, new societal, right, cultural pressures, issues that are not there. 19:15 And it's pretty tough for, for the CEO of Google to say, "Hey, keep that stuff outside. We're making this stuff, but we, we don't really wanna talk about what happens to it," right? Yeah. Or how it's used. 19:25 And that, that seems to be the position, which is where this sort of neutral creative technology, which is a myth, there's no such thing. And so, um, 19:34 the what gets done with this tech, right, I think is, is another thing, right? But, um, a topic for a future show. I, I know we're focused on search today. 19:43 In thinking, in doing some reading ahead of the show, right, I came across, like I said, this article from Insight Partners about future search. 19:49 And the thing that I take away from all the reading was it is a pretty significant change. And again, the surprise of we think search is sort of search, but this movement towards 20:00 contextual search to, to search, which is really aggregated and sort of presented to you in its, in a, in a format that takes the links and the sources down one level. 20:10 I find that very interesting because we're, we're now have a search engine that's actually writing a little essay, a little report to you, and not just giving you a whole bunch of links. 20:20 Um, that means the people who have the links are, are, again, one level below, right? Again, and so the, the article was about, you know, is SEO gonna die or, or- Yeah... how is it changing? 20:30 Because that's the, that's the model that's dr- that's driven Google to the, to where it is today. 20:34 Uh, if all of a sudden now what the d- what the system is doing is really is composing, right, versus presenting, because that's, I think that's the difference. 20:43 I look at the screenshots of the new, the what they, what does Google call it? SGE, search generative experience, right? SGE is the new thing and the preview, um, 'cause I have the preview. 20:51 What you're seeing is a composition of information, not a list of information, and I find that really interesting. 20:59 Instead of a bunch of links that would be put in project management, for example, you don't just see links to project management. 21:04 What you see is an article about project management or an explanation of what it is, and bullet points. 21:11 Al- almost like I said, like a little report in half a page, which is seems like a minor change, but it's- No, it's huge... it's huge, right? 21:19 It's a huge- Well, and I thought you'd, uh, I thought you'd appreciate the little double entendre in our, uh, in our title for this week, uh, how is changing search for good, right? Question mark, though, right? Yeah. 21:29 Because yeah, and, and, and it's, it's not just, you know, you know, I'll, I'll, I'll try to avoid the societal conversation and keep this more of a technical conversation or a bit, well, a business conversation. 21:39 But, you know, it, it, it's, it's huge also from just the user standpoint and the business standpoint. 21:45 I mean, I mean Google, the, you know, depending on how you add it up, you know, Google Search, YouTube, uh, AdWords, you know, that, that entire suite is responsible for about 175 billion, with a B, dollars in, in revenue, right? 22:02 So, you know, anything that's gonna change that is, uh, is tough. 22:06 And, you know, a lot of people, like I said before, have been kind of critical that Google has been, you know, a little slow to the, you know, the, the, the large language model thing, and they had the kind of an epic failure with, uh, the last iteration of, uh, Gemini. 22:22 Um, you know, maybe there's bigger reason, right? This is a business model, a potential business model shift, you know, uh, uh, for them. 22:31 Um, and, you know, I think that's part, there was, there was an article, what sparked this topic for me even before I realized this conference was gonna, you know, announce this this week, um, was that they, they were talking about charging users for AI-based search- Mm-hmm... 22:47 which would be the biggest shakeup of the search business in whatever, 20 plus years, right? Yeah. And, and, and the, the other interesting thing is, uh, uh, the it's not just Google, right? 22:58 Because the number you give is just Google, but what about the entire ecosystem? 23:01 As you and I know, there are hundreds if not thousands of people who make a living optimizing SEO, teaching you how to use, you know, how to get your product in the right place. 23:09 Advertising firms that are buying space, that are buying all kinds of different things. That if as the model changes, right, and that's, I think that's the new head of search at Google, right? 23:18 The entire, that will ripple through the whole ecosystem, and now suddenly we're looking at a completely different business architecture, right? Which is, which is expands from what Google does. 23:28 Every time Google changes search, there are winners and losers, a- as the Insight Partners note. The, this is gonna even bigger. So, so what happens now, right? What, how does this system get, how do the entire... 23:38 It's every, every, just every website has some connection to this issue, right? And so now all of a sudden you need to be found. 23:44 How are you going to be found if you don't make it into this little essay that somebody writes or, or the machine writes about whatever the topic happens to be? Mm. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. 23:54 Well, you, you know, you, 'cause you have, right, you have this kinda, I mean, not only cottage industries, but ev- every business from a mom and pop st- local mom and pop store- Yeah. Right... 24:03 up to, to large enterprises that have really, and, and, and, and kind of this cottage industry of, you know, you know, agencies that focus on Google Ads and, and like you say, other, other, others like it. 24:16 Um, and, you know, that's all based on, you know, this model. So if this model changes, uh, it's got huge ramifications. But one of the questions is- Can it change, right? 24:29 I mean, I mean, there- so there's this company which, uh, is one of the many, you know, companies that, you know, are supposedly the reason why Google's thinking about this because, you know, not only are they a little bit behind with, you know, things like OpenAI, and they realize that that's gonna, that's gonna change things, but there's some direct competitors- Yeah... 24:46 uh, to, to Google Search emerging. There's a company called Perplexity- Perplexity, yeah... which is one of the fastest growing AI startups. They're valued at, like, 500 million. They've got 100 million monthly users. 24:57 Um, but even they, when they originally launched, announced that they were going to make, uh, ad-free searches, uh, and they've kinda, uh, brought that back. 25:09 They, they, they're now, you know, having, you know, building in advertising. 25:13 Um, so, you know, but their, but their original mission statement, and this gets back to, I think a, a show we had a while ago, which was more about, you know, the s- the, the credibility of information on the internet- Right... 25:27 uh, with the changing search, right? 25:29 The, their, their mission statement was initially that, you know, search should be free from the influence of advertising-driven models, and now even they are going to an ad, a- ad-based model. 25:40 Well, the, the, uh, and there is a big sort of cognitive shift, too, when you look at, at Google's concept of SGE, right? And that is the... I've always said I don't, 25:49 I don't like the term artificial intelligence because I think it's augmented intelligence, just the way Google augmented memory, right? Google was, is just like a, a big extra memory bank for us, right? 25:59 So if you're gonna look up who was the 12th president, you don't have to re- memorize it. [laughs] You can just ask Google, "Who was the 12th president?" 26:05 So it's not very smart, but it is, but it does have a lot of memory of things. The move to SGE is more in the direction of augmented, right? Um, because, you know, you have this, this, this sort of aggregator, right? 26:20 This in- this interlocutory between you and those links. That may seem like a, an accuracy, but that's, it's a huge deal because what Google is saying is, "Don't worry about the source at first pass." 26:30 And it's this concept, right, zero click search, which means that, that you, you search something and you just go with whatever appears on the first page. This is even more so in that direction, right? 26:39 Because the idea is if you click on project management and in half a page you've got everything you need to know about project management and what it is, if you're looking for a simple definition, you're not gonna click on anything anymore. 26:48 So, so whatever it is that is being presented to you becomes the, the definitive statement. I think it's more like Wikipedia in a sense. Funny enough, right, structurally, where Wikipedia, that article is the summation. 27:01 The links are still there, right? They're still hyperlinks. But Wikipedia, if you search Battle of Hastings, it doesn't give you a whole bunch of links, right? There is an article about the Battle of Hastings. 27:13 And so funny enough, Google's is starting to look structurally more like in that, in those previews, like a Wikipedia article- Yeah... on the keywords that you're searching, right? 27:22 The other thing that's interesting, too, they announced this visual search was getting upgraded. Yeah. So you, you show a broken whatever ASCO machine, washing machine and tell it, "How do I fix it?" 27:34 And it knows I'm looking at a picture of an ASCO washing machine and something's not working right. Um, I find that also to be really interesting. 27:41 And also, way, it probably way more dangerous, um, because now you're dealing with s- you know, to your point, right? They take a picture of you in the street and I ask Google, "Who's that person?" Right? 27:51 Well, I think of, think about, you know, there was some regulation, I think it was a couple years ago, where people, it seemed pretty, pretty impactful at the time but, you know, this is on another scale, um, a- around affiliate marketing, right? 28:06 Mm-hmm. Where people were creating content that looked like real content, editorial content, but it was really more advertorial content. 28:13 And so, you know, all of a sudden now you see these, these disclaimers that say, you know, "This writer may receive, uh, an affiliate commission for," you know, uh, links back to this article. 28:23 But, you know, i- imagine that model where you're not confronted with a list of links to figure out on your own which one is credible. 28:31 "Oh, I want the click on The Wall Street Journal instead of JohnDoe.com," or some of these people, uh, you know, who are buying up domains and, and are not credible media companies or whatever. 28:42 Um, now, you know, as we talked about with, um, there was the author of the, the history... It was History Disrupted? What was the name of the book? Yeah. History Disrupted. Jason Steinhauer, right. 28:52 Jason Steinhauer, right? Like, what, you know, how, how do you validate the, the q- the, the integrity of the content if you don't know if that content is advertised? 29:01 At least right now there's something on the top of the Google search that says sponsored. Sponsored, right. Right? 29:06 But if it's a summary coming to you from a, from a chatbot that may or may not have that, that footnote or credit on it, where is it coming from and did they pay to get that in front of you? 29:15 Because that, to me, is the only way, you know, Google and its competitors can, can make this jump. 29:22 I mean, there's, there's talk about them charging for AI, but I don't, I don't see, I don't see the average consumer pulling out their wallet and, and, and paying for an AI search. That's a pretty... 29:35 I mean, it's possible, but it's a pretty big paradigm shift. It's a big shift. A- and, and again, you, you can imagine, like, when you pull on these magazines and it says sponsored article, right? 29:46 And it look, it looks just like- Yeah... 29:49 like, I think Forbes does this all the time, where it looks like a regular article and you start reading it and you realize, no, this is being paid boy- by the Saudi Tourist Board or whatever. 29:56 So the, the same thing might happen here, where it, it becomes... What you're gonna have is let's say you wanted to buy an answer, right? Right. Yeah. 30:06 You go, okay, when somebody puts in project management, okay, Monday decided that it wants to own the project management answer. It sounds kooky, but it's not that kooky, right? 30:15 Where I, I, I wanna sponsor the answer to a question, right? And the more popular the question, the more, the more it, the more it's worth to be included in that article, right? 30:28 That's a, it- it's, it's like it isn't even, like, keyword, it's just that what are people asking questions about- And I wanna be part of that answer. 30:37 Well, and, and the inter- and the internet is based on, e- even with the Google, the current Google search model for the last 20-plus years at least, right, is based on links. 30:47 Think about SEO, even what you're talking about, even sponsored links, it's based on links. 30:52 It's about you being presented with a bunch of links, some advertising around those links, and someone getting paid or paying for, uh, you, you know, clicking on that link. 31:01 In this, in this model, in theory, there's no links. So if you're the publisher, this gets back to, we talked about journalism, right? Yeah. 31:08 This gets back to the news companies, the media companies, or anybody else that wants to be the recipient of a link, someone who's invested huge amounts of money into publishing content to get traffic back to their site. 31:21 Now they don't... you don't need to go to their site. Right. 31:24 And b- and, and digging even deeper, right, the original model w- of Google was the more people who link to your site, the more authoritative you became, right? Yeah. 31:33 If you're writing on whatever, the fact that other people were pointing traffic towards you gave you credibility within the algorithm. Now, is that still the paradigm? If not, what is? And again, I think that the, 31:44 your, your... this removal even o- not that a link is the source, although sometimes it is, but to the, to the user, you're taking even one step back. And I find two things interesting just on this topic. 31:55 One is I noticed that Siri always gives, I always say Sydney always s- Siri always footnotes, right? So Siri says, "According to Wikipedia," according to whatever, right? 32:06 S- Siri is funny because Siri cites sources if y- at least these days when you ask it a question. I find that interesting. And then, and then I do think this is a big change. I was... 32:16 There's somebody who I was listening to who was asking a search question on their, on their iPhone, and you think they're asking Google, but they weren't. They were asking ChatGPT. It's funny you mention Siri- Yeah... 32:28 because, you know, there's, there's this, um, there's this thread online about Google reportedly in negotiations to build its Gemini AI into iPhones. Hmm. 32:45 Which would be a blo- a blockbuster deal, right? Of, uh, especially where there's been some disconnect, right? I mean, Google Maps used to be on iPhones, and they pulled that deal a couple years ago. Right. 32:56 They used to be together. Yeah. Right. Yeah. 32:57 So, uh, but that's impactful because, you know, at the end of the day, I think who wins, and, you know, Carlos, you and I said this I think, like, over a year ago, but, um, whi- which was that whoever owns the assistant, the thing that sits on your phone or, you know, gives you ac- y- wins at this. 33:14 You know, you know, Bill Gates also said it, so he gets all the credit, but we said that, Carlos. [laughs] You and I said that, uh, a while back because at the end of the day, nobody wants to... 33:22 I mean, my wife even the other day said, "Okay, w- you know, I, I think I know what, what ChatGPT is now, but how do I get to it," [laughs] right? She's not a technical person. She's not a business person, right? 33:33 She's an average consumer, uh, who doesn't stay up, uh, you know, up on this stuff. 33:38 And, you know, it's not intuitive or, or even obvious to the average human being, you know, like it is to us maybe, where, where to access this thing. But when it's the button on your phone by default- Mm-hmm... 33:52 then this thing changes very quickly, right? A- and puts itself in between you and whatever else that you're looking for, right? Which is what Google did in a, in a very basic way. 34:02 When you think about it, the, the, it's... Google is remarkable because it's such a, like, structurally basic thing, right? 34:09 I know it's, it's incredibly complex algorithmically, mathematically behind the scenes, but as, as a machine-to-person interface, it's always been the little box, right? And it, it's sort of stayed the little box. 34:20 And so now that little box, and we talked about this years ago, right? What, what, what would get rid of the little box? Well, the answer is a conversation. Yeah. A machine that talks to you like a person. 34:31 And it's funny, I was, uh, talking to somebody the other day and, and, uh, who's a CTO, and she happened to n- no, she met- noticed that I was doing this PhD program, and she said, "What's your PhD in?" 34:44 I said, "It's in language and rhetoric." She said, "You know that's a tech PhD from now on." Wow. And I hadn't, yeah, and I hadn't thought about that. She... And I said, "What do you mean?" She goes, "That's it. 34:54 That's..." Because r- I see it every day. We're, we're... it's language, right? You're getting a doctorate in language. 34:59 That, that you're getting actually what's, what will be in a couple of years, right, [laughs] uh, a, a, a tech PhD, which is language and, and rhetoric. And, and so I think that's really interesting, the move. 35:10 We talk about this distinction between technology and the humanities, right? And this, this question of what's an English degree for? 35:16 Well, funny enough, right, it's, it isn't that the English majors have to go to the machines. The machines are coming little by little, right, to, to the people who are, who studied language. 35:26 And I find that really interesting because these interfaces are that. And I, and I, I think I mentioned a couple weeks ago, I was on Photoshop, which I use, right? 35:33 I use Adobe s- stuff all the time for film and editing, and I got this question, "Do you wanna turn on AI in Adobe Photoshop?" Yeah. Right. And suddenly, just type what you want. 35:43 Make the house yellow, and it makes the house yellow. Forget the, the weeks of tutorials and learning how to remove a background or share something, right? Or learn how to grab or lasso tool. It's all gone. 35:52 You just tell it, and it's wonderful. [laughs] Right? Yeah. That's, that, and that's, I mean, that's always the thing with technology, right? You know, you know, I, I don't, I don't wanna know what's in the iPhone. 36:03 Right. I just wanna know that it makes phone calls and plays music, right? That was the beauty of Apple marketing for the longest time. And, you know, I, I'm just very interested to see who wins. 36:12 I, I think anybody who puts this device, you know, on everybody's- Yeah... puts, puts this thing on, you know, easy to access. It, you know, you don't have, like, you don't have to know, oh, this is the one for graphics. 36:24 This is the one for language. Yeah. This is the one for this. It's just one button. It's sitting on your device. And I, I think, you know, I saw some articles that, that keep saying Apple's the dark horse here. 36:34 They've been even further behind b- you know, Google and Microsoft on this. They've been kinda, kinda quiet. 36:39 Maybe this Google negotiation is part of the reason, but, um, you know, they have the data They have the access. I don't know what the market share of iPhone is. 36:49 I know it's not what it was a couple years ago, but it's still significant. Mm. Um, I think, you know, they, they, they, they could emerge, you know. Um, I still think Amazon, you know, could emerge. 37:00 I mean, they, they've been doing voice longer than anybody else, I think. 37:04 Um, it never actuated into this real personal assistant that we all wanted it to always, I wanted [chuckles] it to, to become, other than turning lights on and playing music. But- Right... 37:14 you know, maybe the capabilities are there. 37:16 Um, but then I also wonder, can a, can a big company, like an Amazon, like a Google, who would be forced to really cannibalize their traditional revenue streams, can these guys ever really, 37:31 you know, be the w- be the one? Uh, you know, do you, you know... Is it, is it the, is it really the disruptors that always win? 'Cause when Google took on search, they were the disruptor, right? 37:39 They weren't the big guy. Now, now, now, now all of a sudden they're the big guy, and you see something like OpenAI come along and disrupt, right? I think you can, and, and if... 37:49 Automotive industry is a good example, right? 37:51 Tesla kinda has had it its way for a long time, but, but I, I think that you're, you're now starting to see the big companies come online with phen- phenomenal product that's as good if not better. Right? 38:02 And, uh, I think that's an, that's a case study of incumbents, century-old incumbents that are responding, I think, relatively well to this massive disruption of... 38:13 Again, kudos to, to Musk and to Tesla for making the case that this is real, that it could be, that this was the future, but it's not their game anymore, right? And, and what... And you know what it is too? 38:23 You, we just saw this week about, you know, the electric vehicle tariffs. Once you start putting up tariffs, what does that really say? It said that you need artificial support, right? That's life support. 38:33 Because if you were fr- if it was pure competition, then you'd be in trouble. So what do you do? You put up, you restrict imports, you put tariffs on imports. That, that, 38:45 you know, again, back to capitalism, quote-unquote, with a big C, a little C, right? [chuckles] Yeah. You know, capitalism is great. CEOs at Ford and GM are, are wonderful. 38:52 They're all capitalists until, until the global capitalist says, "You know, I can deliver a electric vehicle for two-thirds of what you can." 38:59 Oh, in that case, let's run to the White House and let's go get some tariffs put on Chinese vehicles. Let's... Right? If American consumers wanna buy Chinese cars, why can't they? Yeah. Yeah. 39:07 If this is really a capitalist economy, right, quote-unquote, and these are people who run these companies are really capitalists, then why are they stopping BYD and Geely and lots of other companies for importing product that's really good, that costs a lot less, and they have to compete on fair terms, right? 39:21 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So I, I think that, that aside, that was my rant for the day, but back to the issue at hand. 39:28 What, what I find real interesting is, is what you were saying, which is this ancient interface mechanism, right, of just talking to somebody. I wanna understand the question, right? 39:39 Let's find the answer to a, to a question. Back to Platonic dialogues, which were a search for answers in many cases. Can you say this is the fundamental human way in which we wanna interact with everything. 39:51 So the more the tech moves towards the very, very ancient paradigm of a conversation, right, like you said, that's, that's the winner. Yep. Yep. That's, you, you- Yeah, I would say think, think of the, the, uh, the i-... 40:05 And, and we're getting closer to it, right? We're getting closer to this idea of a, of a universal assistant, right? Where I don't have to have, you know, uh, uh, Alexa on my phone. 40:16 I, I didn't disable my Alexa, so it's gonna go off. But I, I don't need to have Alexa in my house and Google on my phone or Siri on my phone, and ChatGPT on my, on my browser, right? 40:27 Um, you know, you're, you're, you're gonna get to this point. 40:29 Uh, and some of these other announcements, which, you know, we talk about the business model a lot here in search, but there's some really, really interesting announcements with some of this Google Gemini stuff this week. 40:39 Uh, it's really multimodal. It's, it's really having it with you all the time. 40:44 You know, uh, it, it's g- it's, it's getting to the point where it's, it's like Star Trek where you have a, a communicator or a, a computer with you at all times. 40:53 Or Her, if you love the movie Her, you have this thing, you know, constantly, uh, with you. But, you know, it's, it's, it's getting there. And I think the closest to that is Apple Watch, right? 41:03 The, the, i- if you have the, the... If you have the Watch, you don't really need to carry a phone, not really. Just for the camera, right? 41:10 But I can, maybe in the, in the next vert by 10, they could say, "Okay, what am I looking at?" And it's, "Oh, that's an oak tree," right? Or, you know, Sir- you know, "Hey-" Yeah... "where do I need to go now?" 41:21 And, and a- and like you said, it's the race is on. I was in a ex- Volvo XC40 recently, and it has the Google interface. So there's no more putting in an address. That, that's archaic now. 41:32 You just say, "Google, take me home," and it, and it ups your house and it shows you how to get home. It's not driving you there yet, but it will soon, I would imagine. Or at least helping you get there. 41:41 And so, yeah, it's that, that idea of I, I don't want... The best machine becomes invisible, right, Dan? Right? Yeah. Or at least unnoticed. 41:50 It's just a thing that you, that, that's part of your world and, and part of your day. So one of, so one of the applications that they demoed at the conference was, you know, exactly what what you're getting at. 42:03 You know, where it, I think right now they're calling it Google Lens. Um, but yeah, this thing will, will answer questions about whatever you point the camera at, right? 42:12 So, you know, they showed a demo of a woman trying to get a, a, a broken turntable. Remember turntables? Anybody know what a turntable is on this thing? Uh- Yeah... a, a record player, an old record player. Yeah. 42:22 [chuckles] Um, and the Google identified that the record player's arm was needed adjusting, and it automatically presented her with, you know, a few options for video as well as text-based instructions on how to do it. 42:35 It identified, uh, the, the c- the make and model of the turntable, so I guess if they did have to order a part, she'd know what part. I mean, think about the ramifications for tech support, field work, right? 42:47 Um- Tomorrow services... yeah Yeah. And then, and the other, the other big thing that jumped out to me was this idea of kinda multi-step, you'll... And you'll appreciate this as a researcher, multi-step reasoning. 43:00 So you can kinda find several layers of information on a topic, uh, that you're searching for with, with contextual depth. It reminded me to show my dorkiness, you know, where you'd... 43:10 where you see these Star Trek characters talking to the computer and reasoning back and forth with the computer and saying- Right... 43:15 "Hey, uh, you know, now change the language to this," or, "Change the environment to that," and, you know, working with a computer to, like, solve complex, uh, uh, problems. 43:25 And, and so there's, there's some examples that they showed of, you know, people trying to, you know, ultimately, you know, plan a trip. 43:32 If you think about all the layers involved in planning a trip or a vacation, uh, and how many different searches simultaneously you have to do. 43:39 So, so yeah, to your point though, you know, if, if, if we can just get the outcome with picking up our phone, that's, that's, that's who wins- Interesting... if you can, if you can deliver that. 43:49 And you see the beginnings of that, right? If you go on ChatGPT, you say, for example, "Who was William Wordsworth?" And it'll tell you this was the, you know, romantic poet, et cetera. What are some of his... 43:59 You can ask, you know, "What are some of his most famous poems?" And it'll give you Intimations and Immortality or whatever happens to be. And, "What else did he write?" And you just... 44:07 You can, you can begin to see this conversation, right, with this technology as you explore, in this case, you know, this particular writer or poet, and what was the writer about. 44:18 So you s- you see the beginnings of that, and you can imagine this is moving so quickly, maybe within 10 years you do have that, right? You, you don't have... Like, it kills the apps in my opinion, right? 44:29 Uh, because I, I think in, in, like we saw a preview in the T-Mobile project they did with Brain AI earl- I think it was earlier this year, where there are no apps on the phone. 44:39 The phone OS reconfigures itself depending on the task. So the phone morphs, right? Yeah. It, it becomes the travel thing when you're wanting to book a, a flight. 44:51 It becomes the weather when it want, when, when you want the weather. So I, I liked it, that idea, 'cause I, I, I think even apps are... The time for that has sort of come and gone. 44:59 It's time for the device to understand what it is that I'm asking for at that moment, and why should I have to be s- swiping across 40 different apps to get to the one I'm looking for? If I, if I'm... 45:10 If I need to pull up an insurance card, right, for my car, then it just say, "Show me the insurance card," it should know it's on my Farmer's app, and this is how you go in there and get it, and just give me the card. 45:21 So the, that layer of interactivity, human-like interactivity, seems a lot closer now than it did even just five years ago, right, Dan? 45:32 And I, I- I, I think, I think, uh, yeah, I think what you're talking about is access, right? Yeah. 45:36 But, but also the, the, the, the, the next iteration and, and, and kinda the promise behind, at least as I saw it early on, the, the promise behind the idea of digital twins was- Yeah... 45:48 to be able to predict what you want, right? 45:51 The, the, the, the case study that I saw, I think it was, uh, Toronto International Airport, where, you know, you walk in to the airport and it knows what airline you are, it knows your ticket status, it pulls up your ticket, your baggage information, it tells you what gate you need to go to. 46:08 It tells you that there's a Starbucks on the way, orders your favorite cup of coffee so you can pick it up on the way there, right? I mean, there's... 46:15 To me, and if I'm, if I'm wrong and it's more complicated, somebody can let me know, but to me, all the pieces are there. 46:21 I think it's more of a business model question of how do I monetize that [laughs] if I- But also-... if you don't have to create... 46:27 If you don't have to manually do that, back to the search, if you don't have to manually do that search on your own, then how do I monetize that? But also security, right? 'Cause once you have that system- Yeah... 46:36 in place, anything goes wrong, you're not going anywhere today. Yeah. Right? True. So, and, and as we see in China, you can be controlled. 46:44 And so, uh, right, we know with that system, the social credit system where you get points for this, point for that. 46:50 You know, you don't have enough points, you can take the local bus, you don't get on the express bus, [laughs] right? Yeah. So there's this, you know, you can't use, uh, public transport. And so to the... 47:00 Once you have the system in place, then we go back to the aut- authoritarian kind of nightmare of, well, okay, great, now the, the... 47:08 whoever controls the system, right, is controlling whether you can even walk into the airport. And as you see in a lot of science fiction work, um, the, you could be shut down remotely. 47:20 Well, and, and, and, and, and the regulators are probably, uh, you know, chomping at the bit here, right? 'Cause with all the regulatory progress, in theory, if I can use that word- Mm... 47:31 you know, in the last six, nine, 12 months, can you imagine the, the, the, the, the potential for monopolization where- Yeah... 47:40 all of a sudden, you know, Starbucks is in that, that workflow, but the local coffee shop, the mom-and-pop coffee shop is not, right? So, you know, it does have ramifications for, you know, small business. 47:52 They might not have- Right... the same pocketbook and access that, you know... I guess, I guess in theory, if you're a local business and you're really good at SEO, you can beat out the AdWords, I think in theory. 48:03 I think some people would say. Right. But what- But you can't, right? In that, that model, they just... Google does a deal with, uh, whoever, and that's it. 48:11 And one more thought, right, before we run out of time, and that is the... which ha- which I don't see discussed in these articles about the future of search is this: If you type in 48:21 Battle of Hastings, what does Google know about you? Because it's just that one thing, Battle of Hastings, right? Well, you're an English speaker, you care... 48:30 Let's just say you care about history, maybe Anglophone, whatever. And so if you have to type a whole sentence or a couple, what it gleans about you goes up exponentially. Mm. 48:42 Because now you have syntax, vocabulary, right? All kinds of other things. And so the, the other thing that isn't being discussed is this, the more you talk to anything, the more it learns about you Yeah Right? 48:54 If, if, if you and I communicate through Morse code, [chuckles] you know, right? What I'm gonna learn about you, right- Oh, yeah... is kinda help, stop, right, cities, you know, boat sinking, whatever, stop. 49:04 And so that's one thing. Or telegram. 49:07 But as, as in, in an interface, in a la- natural language interface, within a few minutes, that thing is gleaning huge amounts of information about how you think, how you talk, education, background, class, race, all kinds of other things, right? 49:23 The, the, what it will learn about you is on a whole nother level. And I, and I know the people who are making this stuff know this, right? And, and that hasn't entered the mainstream yet. 49:36 That every time you ask ChatGPT a question, you're informing it. I, you know, I wrote the article a while back in c- when I left consulting about the 10 laws of consulting. 49:45 Like, one of the, one of the 10 was the ans- you know, the question is the answer. [laughs] And in AI, the question is the answer, right? 49:54 You are, you are answering a whole bunch of questions every time you ask it anything. I can tell you that, right? And if they don't have it yet, they will soon. 50:03 Yeah, I saw, I read something this week about d- uh, marketing strategy and content strategy, and, uh, the author said something to the effect of, you know, the, the, the, the clickbait or the lead magnet is about describing the problem, but the, you know- Mm-hmm... 50:22 the service is in- Mm-hmm... solving that problem. Yeah. Right? But if that paradigm shifts upside down, then all of a sudden, all the people that provide that information are no longer necessary, right? Right. 50:36 And, and, and again, right, w- the ability to glean now or to extract isn't word-based, right? 50:45 It's sentence or even paragraph-based, and that's a, that's a different, that's a different thing than, quote-unquote, keyword. This, this becomes almost ideas, right? You're communicating not just, 50:56 not just phrases, right, or terms to the system. You're communicating, I think, I- patterns of thought, syntactical patterns, a whole bunch more stuff that we don't think of as- Sentiment, yeah... right, sentiment. 51:09 You're exactly right. Sentiment, emotion. So yeah, what we're, what we're... The trade-off is gonna get more complex. We're gonna get an easy... Back again to the break debate of this show right there. 51:19 It'll be much more convenient for whatever, because I can just say, "Turn on the lights," or, you know, w- "Hey, Google," w- you know, "Hey, ChatGPT," whatever. 51:27 But now what you're giving it in return, the price of AI is, I think, is much higher than people think. Well, we shall see. 51:36 But, uh, in the meantime, I'm gonna be more conscious of how I act towards customer service and the guy at McDonald's, the drive-through [laughs] and all of those things, right? It's building a profile. 51:50 Hey, great conversation as always, Carlos. [laughs] Good show. Thanks everybody for, uh, for joining. We're live, uh, every Wednesday. We'll be back Wednesday at noon Eastern, 9:00 Pacific. 52:00 In the meantime, check out irpaai.com to join our free membership or schedule a complimentary industry briefcase briefing session. [laughs] Carlos, have a great week, my friend. Same to you, Dan. I'll see you next time. 52:13 Bye bye. You bet. Thanks, everyone. 52:14 [outro music]