Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Good afternoon everyone, and welcome to another episode of The Digital Leader Show, where each week we discuss key issues and news at the intersection of business, technology, and the humanities in hopes of making you a better digital leader. 0:24 This week we're discussing the rules of persuasion with our own Carlos Alvarenga, plus other headlines for digital leaders from the world of enterprise technology. We're live each Wednesday at noon Eastern, 9:00 Pacific. 0:35 We're on YouTube, LinkedIn, and Twitter, and the audio recording is available on m- major podcast platforms as well. 0:41 Don't forget to check us out at deinetwork.com for coaching and assistance, industry briefings, and client peer-to-peer groups. I'm Dan Goodstein. 0:50 I head up Digital Enterprise Institute, as well as our sister organization, the Institute for Robotic Process Automation and Artificial Intelligence. 0:58 We're a professional association and peer-to-peer research network providing education, networking, and advice to over 130,000 members globally all around automation, enterprise AI, and digital transformation. 1:11 It's at this point where I would normally, uh, introduce our co-host, Carlos Alvarenga, but I'm gonna inv- invite him to join us as our, our guest today. 1:19 He's a researcher and author, an educator at the University of Maryland and Georgetown, former advisor at EY and Accenture, and most importantly, the author of the new book, The Rules of Persuasion. 1:31 Carlos, good afternoon. Good afternoon, Dan. Great to be back as a guest this time. Thank you. Yes, you're a guest this time, which means I'm not gonna be as nice to you. 1:39 I gotta ask you all the tough questions- [laughs] Right... and, and all that stuff. But no, in all seriousness, um, you know, this, uh, this book is kinda how you and I started this show. 1:48 I think I interviewed you initially for, um, you know, some of the concepts in the book while you were writing it, and how it related to the, the business and, a- and tech world, and then, uh, we got to talking, enjoyed it, and, and decided to do it live in front of people every week. 2:04 That's right. The origin of the show is the book, and it'll be nice to talk about it now that it's almost out, right, and available for people to read. 2:11 So before we jump into the topic of the day, Carlos, any, uh, any, any news headlines, uh, catching your eye? Quite, quite a bit, right? Well, it's a Fed day, so of course everybody's sort of watching that. 2:22 The markets are kind of holding steady. We'll see what happens in the afternoon. 2:26 Uh, I've been following the, the First Republic story a lot and, and you, I guess it was the, you know, the Milken Conference going on this week. 2:34 And so there were a couple people saying that this is not, still isn't the last domino apparently, or some of the insiders are saying that there's more to come. So I think that's got people a little bit skittish. 2:44 And then there was a new short report from Hindenburg, right, on Icon Group. So, uh, we saw what happened with the, the folks in India, which took a pretty serious toll on them, and we'll see what happens. 2:56 Now with Icon Group responding that they don't think it's, you know, it's, the report is sort of self-justifying and self-serving, and they stand by their statements. 3:05 But, uh, Hindenburg has a good track record, so we'll be following that one as well. Yeah. I think it's... 3:10 You know, I, I actually was asked this morning, uh, by some members about, uh, who are, who are not in the US, who, uh, you know, about the, the state of the, the banking, uh, system, uh, here and the, you know, or at least what's, what's trickling in, in the news to, to them. 3:28 And, you know, I said, "I think it's, I think it's tough right now." I, I don't, I don't think you're gonna see a, you know, traditional banking collapse. 3:36 I don't, I don't think people have lost confidence in the banking system as a whole. Uh, but you gotta think that it's, it's, it's gonna be turbulent, uh, for any, any small, midsize bank for the foreseeable future. 3:50 Well, the report that came out, I think it was Monday, right? The SEC's report saying that the oversight was just, you know, has to be completely revamped. 3:58 It was, it was very, very critical of how the banks sort of, especially SVB, ran itself. 4:03 So clearly there, there is a lot of, lot that has to be cleaned up from a regulatory oversight, back to risk management conversation we had a couple weeks ago, right? 4:12 The d- the report, if you read it, it's, it's pretty grim reading. Um, it's, you know, one of these you don't wanna know how the sausage is made, right? 4:18 But it's a bank, not a sausage factory, so you would expect a little bit higher schemes, but apparently there's a little bit of a, a mess that has to be cleaned up inside the risk management teams in some of these places. 4:29 Yeah. Yeah. 4:31 Yeah, and speaking of risk management, uh, you know, there's a couple headlines this week, you know, as we, as we talked about and predicted, not, not a big surprise, but, uh, you know, some of the crypto exchanges, Coinbase and, and others, uh, you know, starting to s- uh, set up operations outside the US. 4:48 So, um, you know, you, you brought up an interesting point a couple weeks ago of, you know, hey, this thing was supposed to be, you know, deregulated, so, so no surprise there. 4:57 But, you know, others are saying, you know, hey, this thing, you know, is better off having some level of regulation for, you know, to make it more, you know, legitimate to the average investor. So who knows, right? 5:08 I'll tell you one other little follow-up. I've mentioned a couple weeks ago that I'd gotten a solicitation from Amazon's new One Medical, like the sort of offering, right? 5:16 And I had my checkup yesterday, and I tell you, it was remarkable. It was, uh, I- my old doctor went concierge, right, and he wanted thousands to continue. I went to One Medical. It looked the same to me. 5:31 It was beautiful office, penthouse sort of near where I live. They started exactly on time. Doctor took all the time in the world. They have a, a lab that looks like a professional lab, and the annual cost is $144. 5:46 So if I were a concierge medicine person, I would be very worried, because what I saw yesterday was exactly a concierge. And they have an app. You do all your, if you have any prescriptions, can be done through the app. 5:57 They're on call 24/7 with doctors by video, and, uh, that doesn't cost anything. So, um- 6:14 Of Amazon's healthcare, uh, it looked pretty good as a, as a demo, you know, as a beta product to me. So- Yeah. 6:21 I'll tell you what, you know, I, I, I recently had a, a few, a few doc- new doctor's appointments and, uh, admittedly been a while since I, I've g- gone for my checkup and all that stuff. 6:30 So, um, I was, I was surprised just from a tech standpoint, I, I was surprised at how far, um, you know, many of the doctor's offices, you know, local doctor's offices, um, how, how advanced they've gotten. 6:46 Um, or at least more advanced they've gotten since, you know, I, I, probably pre-COVID where I was really, you know, going to doctors and things. 6:53 And, um, you know, interesting now a lot of it's digital, a lot of it's, uh, you know, app-based, like you say, around appointments and things. 7:01 But I'll tell you, the challenge still is, um, they all use their own technology and they all use their own apps. 7:08 So it's almost back to, you know, okay, yes, it's digital, but as, as our guest last week, Bill Galucia, was talking about, you know, you know, one issue is lack of digitization, but even if you solve that problem, it's lack of integration between all these platforms. 7:21 So now I've got three different apps with three different doctors [laughs] and it's- Well, and that's-... it's a little bit better, but not great. [laughs] Yeah, and that's where Amazon had scale comes into play, right? 7:30 'Cause like I said, if you ever need a prescription, it connects to Amazon Pharmacy, right? Yeah. And you can do it through the app. And so you can imagine, right, the ecosystem of the physical location, right? 7:40 If you ever need a script, it's gonna come right from them. So again, to me, as the, as the, as the future of where Amazon's vision is, I was pretty impressed. 7:49 Considering this is just a limited rollout in just a few markets, uh, if this is the, if this is the rough version, boy, I, I, I wanna see it when they're, when, when the real full-blown model rolls out. 7:59 It's gonna be something to see, I think. 8:01 So Amazon is always, you know, as, as much as they get beat up sometimes, I, I, I just think it's a phenomenal management team and you see the, the vision in this experience I had yesterday. Yeah. 8:12 And we're gonna have, uh, Trent Gillespie back on. Uh, he was on a couple weeks ago talking about, uh, Alexa and privacy, ex- uh, ex-Amazon exec. 8:20 Uh, but he also was involved in, uh, logistics and a lot of the delivery services- Yeah... uh, that Amazon's rolled out, um, uh, from a technology standpoint. 8:29 So he'll be on again in a couple weeks to talk more about the supply chain and, and delivery, uh, side of things. But, uh, yeah, no, always, always interesting. 8:37 The, the other, Carlos, before we jump in is, um, you know, there's been, uh, you know, a couple stories this week around, you know, what we've talked about a lot, especially recently with ChatGPT, what happens to the publishers, what happens to the media. 8:52 Yeah. 8:53 Um, and so I saw a piece that I think I sent you of, uh, this European Union regulation actually adding a stipulation in the, in the new guidelines, in the new regulation in Europe, uh, where the, the, the AI, any AI has to cite copyrighted material. 9:10 Yeah. Uh, but then your, then your buddy, uh, Elon Musk came out a couple days ago and said that he's building a pay per article subscription front end for Twitter. Well, and then we have the writers' strike. 9:24 And then you have the writers' strike. 9:25 [laughs] Because, and one of the things in the writers' strike is they don't want, they don't want anyone to use AI to write episodes on mater- based on a show that was written by people first, right? 9:37 So y- y- which apparently there were, there have been a couple of examples of that. People have generated episodes of sitcoms and, or s- or, or shows. 9:45 And so the p- a big line item on the writers' strike is exactly that, is, is the fact that they're concerned that in a, in a couple years, right, a writer creates the pilot season, and with one pilot or a couple of pilot seasons, you give it to chat, API, you know, and it just goes to town and writes you five seasons worth of shows. 10:03 Interesting. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. 10:05 And I, I thought it was interesting also, I was, I was watching the, uh, the White House Press Correspondents' Dinner, and the, the comedian actually, um, uh, made a comment, 'cause I guess his father was a journalist, and he made a comment about, you know, basically how the model is broken and, um, he doesn't think that people are gonna pay for news, but that he understands the, the amount of work and money that goes into good journalism. 10:32 So it's, it's an interesting paradox of, um, you know, the, the business model versus the desire for, you know, uh, the quality that you would, that, that you would want from news, uh, without people paying for it. 10:46 It's a good topic for the, another show, right? Because i- if you look at the ones who've done well, like the New York Times, it's had phenomenal success, just the pay all went up, and you have The Economist and FT. 10:56 So the, just like the, the top of the top, right, The Cream, the Wall Street Journal, they do fine in a paywalled world, right? It's, uh, it's the ones sort of below that. 11:06 It's almost like the, the Ivy League is always... All right, Carlos. Uh- Lost you, lost you there for a second. 11:23 Yeah, sorry about that. But we can go ahead and jump in anytime you want, Dan. Yeah, so let's do it, man. So, so, so give us a, give us the setup. 11:30 Tell us, uh, I, I know a little bit, uh, read a little bit, but, uh, tell us about the work that you've been, you, you're really working on for, for a couple years now, right? 11:38 Well, so the, the origin of the book goes back to two years ago. 11:42 I, I was, I started to volunteer on a website called Catchafire, where you can donate your time to help nonprofits, and my very first project was the chairman of an international humanitarian aid agency. 11:54 And as, as he and I chatted, it's, a couple of things struck me. 11:59 Uh, one was about the way he approached public speaking, but the other one was that in looking at the content that he had and, and listening to his speeches and videos, I thought that he wasn't really understanding How persuasion works, right? 12:14 In, in the public context, in the communication context. 12:16 And so, uh, I, I made a PowerPoint deck of a book called The Rhetoric from Aristotle that I read in college, and we went through the PowerPoint deck, and it- he had a phenomenal time in the process, right? 12:28 He completely changed how he approached his public speaking, and I did this several times, and then my wife said, "No, you know, hey, you need to write this down because I think you've done a nice job of encapsulating, and even expanding what was, um, what was Aristotle's original kind of insight." 12:45 And, you know, long story short, two years later, that is the book that will, that will arrive in August, uh, The Rules of Persuasion. 12:53 So, so help everybody watching this understand that, that, you know, they're not, they're not in the wrong place. 12:57 How, how does ancient Greek philosophy apply to the, the world of business and technology that, that we're in now? 13:03 Well, because one of Aristotle's insight is that, is that human communication i- is universal, and so, and p- and, and because so much of communication is persuasion, it is also universal. 13:15 So in almost every professional setting, and many personal ones, when we communicate, we're trying to get someone to agree with us, understand our point of view, take an action, right? 13:26 That we'd like them to take, or to consider something they may not have considered before. So if you think about it, 13:32 I'd say a majority of conversations, like we're having right now, I'm trying to convince someone, right, that my ideas of persuasion are correct, right? Here we are again. 13:42 Um, and yet what I've found is, in, in my coaching is that w- whenever I start to coach and I say, "Can you define what persuasion is?" No one can answer that question. 13:53 And so I found it remarkable that when so much of our success depends on being able to persuade people of things, it is something that at least people who I've coached, and I've coached many, many people, can't even define, much less have studied or considered or thought about. 14:08 And so we've- they've landed in this world where they think persuasion is a soft skill, right? It's an undefined thing. It's some kind of vague set of qualities. Uh, and what I argue in the book is that it's not. 14:21 Persuasion is chemistry. It operates by rules. It is predictable. It can be analyzed across time, place, culture, medium. 14:32 And so, um, the, the main argument of the book is that, is think of persuasion not as a soft skill, but think of it as chemistry. 14:39 And like any chemistry, it can be used for good to make medicine, but it can be used for evil to make poison. 14:47 And I have a whole chapter on what I call the dark side of persuasion, which is what happens when somebody who understands the chemistry puts it to use for the wrong things. 14:55 So that is, I think, the most important takeaway, is understand that this is, um, a systematic, what's called a techne in Greek, right? A, a, an art with a purpose. That's the most important thing to know. 15:11 You know, years and years and years ago, I read a book about, um, uh... It was really about corporate communication. I thought it was about selling. 15:19 Um, and, and what it really was was about kinda internal selling and, and the importance of not only, you know, communicating externally, but communicating internally with a, within an organization. 15:30 And what, what I, what I realized after reading that book wa- a, a lot of things, but one of them was, um, that this is not just... You know, I, I originally thought it was a sales and marketing book, right? 15:40 Which obviously it applies to sales and marketing, but this, this applies really to anybody, Carlos, who is, you know, really trying to communicate or sell and market a concept. 15:50 So yes, salespeople, yes, marketing, PR, c- you know, communications, but really anybody within a, I would say, a big organization, right? It is. A- and I've, and I've coached executives, right? 16:01 In, in public sector companies, in, in nonprofits, in private companies, and one of the big challenges is that Aristotle says there are three, what he calls, what I would call modes. 16:21 The, the first one is character. So who am I listening to? Who's speaking to me? What's speaking to me, right? W- who, who is this entity communicating with me? The second one is argument. 16:35 So argument refers to things like evidence, proofs, witnesses, logic, right? Statistics. And then the last one is emotion. 16:44 So emotion refers to the things that the audience feels as they're r- as they're receiving the message. 16:51 And what I find is that, especially in the professional and business world, most people tend to over-rely on argument and ignore character and emotion. 17:05 Yeah, I think it's especially true when you think about the tech world. 17:09 Uh, you know, you know, I, I meet e- executives every day, and I would say it's, it's largely a, um, A- Americans tend to understand this more than, than some of the people in Asia or even Europe, but, um, engineers and technical people in general tend to have this philosophy of, you know, I'll, I build something and they will come. 17:30 [laughs] And everybody will be interested in it, right? And it just doesn't play out. And it's a huge issue because, as I explained in the book, the, the hardest thing to build and to follow is argument, right? 17:41 I- i- because we're not, we're not really, as human beings, very good at this. And so when that is what you rely on the most, you're almost starting already kind of, you know, uh, on the back foot. 17:52 In fact, I, I explain to people who I coach, y- y- you think about this three parts, right? As like dials. 17:58 So imagine that the, a dial that goes from 0 to 10 for each one of these things, and we say the perfect, the perfectly persuasive message gets a score of 30, right? 18:08 10 points for character, 10 points for argument, 10 points for emotion. When I first meet people- I find they're about a six or a seven. Character is zero, emotion is zero if it, if it's at a negative number- Wow... 18:21 right? And argument is five or a six. So of a 30 possible score, you're getting a five or six. My goal was always to get you into the low 20s at least, right? A- if not higher, if you have some talent toward this. 18:35 And the, and the biggest change is, a good example again, is just character. So we'll say, "Okay, what about you?" 'Cause people are told incorrectly, "You shouldn't be part of the story." 18:45 And this is a huge mistake in my opinion. In fact, Aristotle says, of all the three things, the most important is k- is the speaker's character. 18:52 So what of your story, of who you are, of your history, of what you've achieved, of what you represent or symbolize to an audience, right, is important or helps you persuade. 19:05 That's something that people generally ignore. At the other end, right, which is emotion, which is what are you trying to get your audience to feel? And I... This could be in a corporate setting, right? 19:14 Do you want them to feel pride? Do you want them to feel excited? Do you want them to feel afraid because of competition, uh, inspired? So, uh, the... In order to do that, it's not by accident. 19:25 You have to understand how each emotion is created, how it's generated, what effect it has on the audience. 19:32 And so, uh, this may seem a little bit hard in the beginning, but with practice, it's like playing a- the piano, it becomes second nature over time. 19:41 Why do you think people don't, don't see this as a, as a bigger issue, right? I mean, you, you mentioned before, uh, that this is not a soft skill. 19:49 I mean, may- maybe one of the reasons is people are, especially I think technical people are brought up to say, "Hey, I'm really good at technical. 19:56 I'm a, I'm a zeros and ones person, and I'm not good at that, that EQ side of, uh, of, of things." 20:03 But you're saying this is not a soft skill, so meaning, meaning this is something that is teachable and not necessarily that you're, that you're born with. [laughs] No. 20:12 In fact, one of the things that we, I said about definition, right, when I ask people to explain this is, what we do then is say, well, Aristotle has a very exact one, which is, "Persuasion is a demonstration that something is true or that appears to be true." 20:25 Period, end stop, right? So the definition has many implications, the most important one being that you don't persuade truth, or the appearance of truth persuades, right? And yeah, I'll move a little bit through that. 20:37 And so what that means is that, um, y- you know, persuasion, your job is to get someone to believe that something is true. Unless you're dealing with an irrational person, and sometimes we are, right? 20:52 Persuasion follows by necessity, okay? And so this is, this is to me the most important thing. You know, in Greek we have this word techne, right? And techne is what persuasion is. It is a technical craft. 21:05 And I think the reason why it isn't studied, and I talk about this in my book, is that after World War II, there was a kind of rejection of this, uh, because of what had happened... 21:25 whole kind of end, right? And, and I explain all that in the book. And so it was taken out of the curriculum. 21:32 And I understand that's the reasons why this was done, but unfortunately, because it is chemistry, if you stop teaching chemistry, chemistry doesn't stop working, right? 21:43 It still continues to function, and this is the one reason why I wrote the book. And it's funny because I have a couple of friends of mine who are, who are scholars in this world, right? 21:51 And they didn't want me to write the book. They thought, "This is best left locked away," okay? Um- Because it can be used for evil as well as good, right? It could be used... 22:02 I mean, you just said it, quote, like word for word. It could be... If it falls to the wrong hands, right, you, you're giving them a playbook for how to corrupt language. 22:11 And my counter was, okay, I get that, but I'd rather arm people with the defense, right? 22:18 To be able to recognize when these things are being used in the, in the wrong way, uh, than to, than to not know that this chemistry exists. It is an invisible science in a way, and because it isn't taught, 22:32 uh, we, we kind of go through life not knowing that these, uh, mechanisms exist, right? And, and that they affect us in, um, in many different ways. 22:44 You know, you bring up an interesting point about bringing the three together, right? Uh, 'cause o- one alone i- is, is not enough. 22:51 And I think about the, you know, again, the, the, the more technical people that have built things and they, they decide that it's better just because it's, it's better than maybe the version before it or, or the, or the, or the techne- from a technical standpoint, you know, whatever came before that they were so... 23:07 But, um, I also think about there's, there's so many technologies that never see the light of day because they're not well promoted or marketed or evangelized maybe, right? Yeah, yeah, right. 23:21 And, and also because a lot of times, in my experience, one things that executives get wrong is they fail to distinguish between coercion and persuasion. Hmm. Right? 23:31 It's very easy to think you've persuaded when in fact you've coerced, and I use the example in the book, your boss tells you, "Hey, I just finished this management book," or a book on persuasion, [laughs] "and I think it's a great book. 23:44 You should read it," quote unquote. Okay? So this is the person that controls your living, and just told you, "This is a great book. I strongly suggest you read this book." Have y- and then you read it. 23:56 Do- would- did you read it because you were persuaded to read the book or did you read it because you were coerced? 24:02 And I've said to executives if, ask yourself this question, if you left the organization tomorrow, would your ideas, your projects, the things you care about go with you or would they continue? 24:13 If they disappear when you walk out the door, you're dealing with a coercive- Setting usually, not always, usually, right? If your ideas persist, then you have persuaded your organization that these things are important. 24:26 And I think this understanding of how do these things connect, and, and back to this idea of, of chemistry, right? One of the things that I work with is there are specific formulations. 24:37 You see them in movies, you see them in advertising, you see them in books and literature, music, plays. And so some of them are repeated over and over again. 24:43 Politics, for example, has a very specific set of almost like jars on a shelf that I can take out, right? And sort of pour and, and mix for an audience. 24:51 Um, and i- if you-- it doesn't take a lot to go from not knowing any of this to learning a little bit of how it works, and then suddenly being able to use it. 25:03 And in fact, when we, when I work with someone, one thing that we do is we create-- I ask them to do a persuasion journal. So I say, "Now that you get the rules, right? 25:10 And you understand these 21 elements and how this stuff works, I want you to write down when you see it at work, or in a movie, or in a commercial." 25:19 Because as you start to notice it, you start to understand it and you start to recognize it, which is the first step towards getting better at using it yourself. 25:27 And I, and I have yet to coach someone or work with someone who hasn't been able to improve once they understand that there are rules to how this stuff works then. Yeah. 25:40 I think if you can, um, you know, articulate those rules to somebody and, and, and, and, you know, get them to start following the rules, like you say, and, and anybody can do it, so it's not, it's not just this, uh, this, this, again, EQ thing that, that certain people have. 25:57 So, so give us some examples of, um, I know you have some, some examples of, of real world use cases for this. Yeah. So as I, as I mentioned, right, we have as a, in, as a broad speaking, these three modes, right? 26:09 Of the character of the person speaking, the arguments that are made, and the emotion the audience feels. And one of the things that, that we use as an example in my workshop is the Gettysburg Address. 26:34 What I say is that, uh, there's a reason why this is remembered, right? Lots of people spoke on that day. Uh, that Mr. Former President Harvard famously spoke for two and a half hours. Nobody remembers what he said. 26:46 This speech is two minutes and 48 seconds. There are less than the different versions, let's say two and a half minutes, and it's always been remembered. And we've... And, and when I work, we would read it, listen to it. 26:58 But why is it remembered? If you, if you apply the three modes, right, you'll see them at work inside the speech. 27:06 Or in this case, green is character, so there are appeals to the, to the nation's character, to the character of the audience. 27:12 There are arguments, there are moral arguments, philosophical arguments, claims about debt, what the living owe to the dead, right? 27:20 There's an, a return to our character near the end, and it ends this beautiful emotional appeal to save the nation. And Lincoln, who would've studied rhetoric, right? As, as a st- as a child, right? 27:33 As a young person, would've been very familiar with these three modes and how they work. 27:37 And you, and you see them, if you go line by line, right, in the Gettysburg Address, it's a wonderful example of Aristotle's insights at work. But it's just one. Another one of my favorites is actually just do it, right? 27:50 Just do it, the famous tagline, Dan Wieden's li- line for Nike. Um, if you don't know the story, right? 27:56 Of how it was created, Nike had advertising that was running in print, a lot of different things, different athletes and, and Wieden from Wieden+Kennedy, who was the partner there, thought, "We need a, we need a tagline that connects it all. 28:07 We, we need to, to put one thought in the, in the customer's mind that unites these disparate visual and, um, you know, and, and video and audio messages," right? 28:20 And so he was watching the news apparently, and w- came across the execution of Gary Gilmore, the mass murderer. 28:29 And the story goes from him that when he was being taken to the electric chair, Gilmore was asked, "Do you have any last words?" And his last words were, "Let's do it." Wieden heard this and said, "That's it. 28:44 [laughs] I just need to change one word, right, and I've got it." He took the idea to Phil Knight and to his own team, and everybody hated it. They thought it was terrible. [laughs] We don't need this, right? 28:55 And, and Wieden said in an, an interview one time that it was his character that persuaded them that just try it. They did. It was a hit almost from the word go, right? 29:05 And it, and it's still the tagline of the company and it works because it's all three things, right? First of all, it is technically a counterargument. You have all these reasons why you don't wanna work out. 29:15 Nike says, "Yeah, I understand that." However, right? In response, "Doesn't matter, because you should gonna, you should go and work out." Two, it's a character statement. 29:24 Weak people stay in bed at 5:00 in the morning when it's cold. People of strong character get up and run. People of character do the things that are difficult, right? 29:34 Are you a weak person or are you a person of strong character, right? And then lastly, it's emotion, right? It's, um, 29:42 when they show somebody, uh, scoring a goal, when they show somebody, you know, winning the NBA finals, it's euphoria, right? It's excitement. It's this feel like, don't you wanna feel what they feel? 29:53 Don't you wanna feel the, the endorphins run into your body when you finish the 10K, right? So, and, and in their appeal with celebrities and athletes and sometimes controversial athletes like Kaepernick, right? 30:05 There's always this emotional component, and I tell people, Nike, to my knowledge, has never run an ad- About the benefits of exercise. [laughs] Right. 30:13 It assumes you have that, so now it's why would you exercise with them, right? And in almost every poll of advertising people, this is always rated, you know, the greatest tagline of all time. 30:27 Uh, I think it is, and I think it's, it is because of these three elements at work. And then I'll share one more. In my book I talk, I have a chapter on social media, right, and technology and persuasion. 30:38 And one thing I do is look at the top five tweets of all time, which are right here as of the writing of the book, right, December of last year. And if we were to... 30:48 And in the book I analyze all five, and you'll see at least two, sometimes all three of the modes at work, right? The number one is Chadwick Boseman's family announcement of his death. 30:59 Uh, you've got Elon number two, Obama has three and five, and Biden four, right? 31:05 And you'll see in them the use of the character of the speaker wanting to associate with the right, uh, virtues, uh, the feeling of emotion, of sadness or consolation, right, at the death, right? 31:18 Um, very little argument, 'cause Twitter doesn't really, uh, support logic or evidence. Twitter doesn't or Elon doesn't? 31:33 So it's, uh, i- i- if you look at Instagram, at YouTube, right, Wikipedia, Twitter, like I do in the book, you find that these ideas that were articulated, right, 2,500 years ago, [laughs] uh, they operate exactly the same way. 31:50 Which leads me to a, an interesting question. I gave a lecture about this at University of Maryland, and one of the students asked me, "Is persuasion a uniquely human thing?" Hmm. 32:01 I said, "Well, it depends if you believe in God or not." Because if you look at, if you believe in God, um, I say no, because of the major faiths, right, uh, Abrahamic faiths, the gods use the same rules to persuade. 32:20 Mm. So either, either they're following Aristotle, Aristotle's words apply to divine creatures as well, right? So, uh, there, there is a, a consistency in how the, the literature of divine beings operates. 32:36 So I would say if, if you believe in God, God also, they also follow these rules. Then he said, "What about machines? Uh, can machines persuade?" And I said, "Well, interesting, another interesting question." 32:48 There, there was a project that was concurrent, I believe, with the project IBM had to, to win at Go, right? And it was called Project Debater, and the idea was to create a machine that could debate a human being. 33:01 That was a failure. The, the game machine won, the debating machine lost. And if you watch the interview with the project manager, he says it was m- it was more complicated than the games. 33:13 Uh, trying to persuade someone or to win a debate for the foreseeable future, right, remains, uh, a uniquely human trait. So as we enter the AI ChatGPT area, you know, I think the new Turing test is 33:31 a machine that can persuade you of something, because, um, that still seems to be, you know, slightly, uh, beyond the border of what machines can do. It's a great point, Carlos. 33:43 You know, as everybody, you know, that we talk to is kinda half excited and half freaking out by all these advances, right? Uh, and people saying, you know, "Is it gonna take my job?" And, and all those debates. 33:54 Um, but you know, one of the things that we've talked about, one of the things that I speak about a lot, um, a- and, and, and, and, and this kind of brings up is, you know, this, maybe this becomes your differentiator, right? 34:07 If it, if it's just about the argument part alone, maybe ChatGPT can do that. Uh, but it's probably further away that ChatGPT or something like it can do the, the persuasive side of things. 34:19 So even more of a, of a reason to, to get away from the zeros and ones and the black and white and the argument, but be able to, to live in that gray area and, and, and be able to play the, the character and the, the, the emotion angles. 34:33 A- and by the way, you think about character, that's something, at least for now, right, that is unavailable to ChatGPT. 34:40 You know, we don't, we're, we're not as of now moved by the fact that a machine is telling us to do something. In fact, it would be the opposite. 34:48 I would say character is a, is a, is a negative trait, right, when it comes to, to machines at this point. Um, we don't think of them as, as things to be trusted. And so, um- Mm... 34:59 if, if the character part is based on... Aristotle says for a character to be persuasive, they should know what they speak about, they should speak for the right reasons, and they should mean you well. 35:11 Um, I don't think any of those things apply, right, to machines at this moment for the most part. 35:16 And so, uh, th- there is this realm of building, right, the persuasive character, um, as an executive, as a leader, and having that be integral to the message that you deliver to individuals. 35:29 And I'll give you a good example. 35:30 I work with a chief digital officer in Europe, and he, he had taken over a new role because the company felt that they need to go through, you know, the famous digital transformation, right? 35:41 And, uh, he was really struggling. He'd been there for six months and he told me, "Half my team thinks it's impossible, the other half thinks we don't need it." [laughs] Mm. "And, and so, you know, what do I do?" 35:53 And I said, "Well, let's talk about the character part." And he said, "I, I, I don't, I have no idea what you're talking about. Uh, I, I never talk about myself. I'm not part of the history." 36:02 The more we talked, it turned out that the old, uh, CIO/CDO was very liked, 36:09 and so it left people pretty upset when he was fired and the board decided that he wasn't the right person to do the transformation, so that he had walked into sort of negative situation. Nobody knew who he was. 36:21 Um, they thought he came from a privileged background, which wasn't really the case. And so we s- we worked a lot on... 36:41 Because of the loss of the former, right, CIO, and that became an integral part of rethinking, right, his persuasive strategy. 36:52 Another example was somebody who was phenomenal executive, fashion industry, and she loved argument, right? There's no Excel spreadsheet she never, that she met that she didn't like. 37:02 And, and I, I, I explained to her that the more you like logic, the more you like statistics and facts, the farther away you are from persuading the average person. Yeah. Mm. 37:15 So- So is it, is it primarily credibility, Carlos? 37:18 I think back, you know, even, even what we've done as an association for many, many years is, is help organizations on the vendor side at least to, you know, put out thought leadership and, and, and promote expertise so that when they do engage in, in, in sales and marketing conversations, they, they're doing so from a, a place of, uh, of expertise instead of just salesmanship or just the argument of, "Hey, we've got a better widget." 37:45 Mm-hmm. Well, I... But this is the problem. Their expertise has two components, right? There's argument component, which is, "I know the subject matter," right? Which is helpful. 37:56 But there's also the character of the expert, right? And we've all met experts who, who we agreed knew their stuff, but we hated talking to them, right? We didn't like the interaction. Uh, and I know I have. 38:08 I've met doctors who are like that. Maybe this person is a great surgeon, but he's a jerk, right? I know I'm not talking to this person again. 38:16 Whereas the character that says, "I know something, and I wanna share it with you," right? "I wanna make my expertise useful to you," um, is a completely different character, right? 38:29 The content is the same, both people, but it is the character component that makes a difference, right? I'll give you a really good example. 38:36 I was trying to get someone to, to, to come to one of our, uh, when I was at World50, come to one of our events, and, and he was AI expert. And 38:45 the, the, I, I had talked to somebody who worked with him, and the guy was kind of a jerk. He didn't wanna pass me through to him. And, and I realized after a while that this person really didn't know anything, right? 38:56 Through another friend of mine, I, I connected to the person I was trying to reach and said, "I wanna talk to you about AI." He said, "Call me, I'm gonna be driving from Toulouse to Paris. Call my cell phone." 39:08 And we spent an hour and a half talking in the car about all of his work. And one thing I've learned is that people who really know their stuff, they're happy to tell you most of the time, right? 39:17 They're happy to communicate. The, the character of a true, true expert is almost often defined by a willingness to share what they know because they want, they want you to know it, right? 39:27 And so I think that in the case of saying, "I want to come across as an, someone with expertise," there is knowing the content, right, whatever that happens to be, but there's also the character of, of someone who wants to share that knowledge with you and wants to make you better, right, at your job, and I think that's the part that gets left behind sometimes. 39:48 But, you know, the first example you gave of the doctor, is, is, is there ever a scenario where one of those modes does work on its own? I mean, I think with a doctor, 39:58 I don't like a lot of the doctors that I go to, but they're the best at, at, in their field, and so they've got that credibility. 40:04 And so as much as I hate going, I still go, and I bu- like, my insurance company still bills them [laughs] and I still pay my copay and I still listen to what they say. 40:13 But I'd say even there, there are two, because one is there's the ar- the content of the argument part, but there's an emotion point, which is you're afraid something's gonna go wrong if you don't go. 40:23 Ah, so it's my emotion, not necessarily the, the person- Right... that's selling it. Right. When we talk about emotion, it is what the audience feels. 40:30 So the, you may be with a colossal jerk, but the person is saying, "If you don't do what I'm telling you, you're gonna go to jail," right? 40:39 Then the, then there is the, the evidence or the argument, but then there's also this, this feeling of anxiety, right, or fear or whatever it is that you may have. And two out of three can be very effective. 40:52 There, there are, there's more than one politician who has made a living on the character they build and the emotions they generate, skipping, right, logic and evidence and facts, right? 41:07 In, in fact, we're, we're sort of headed in that way in many cases, right, where so much of political persuasion is built really not on argument. It's, it's the weakest of the three modes, I think. 41:18 Um, a lot of times, you know, this is the, this is the famous video at, at the political convention, right? This is, this is this person when he was born, and he grew up in Kansas, and here's him as a child, right? 41:27 This is the character element, and then there is this rousing speech where everybody feels pumped up to go support this person, right? 41:36 So, uh, political conventions tend to rely on, on character and emotion much more than, than anything else. Well, I, I think that's proven itself out, especially, like you say, politics in the last few years. 41:49 Re- regardless of what side you're on, um, it seems like it's more about the emotion and the, um, the desire for a certain set of beliefs, you know, versus truth and facts in some cases, right? 42:05 People are kinda overlooking some of the, some of the, the argument pieces, the truth pieces in- Right. And so-... in order to fit that. You're right. And, and some things that are new, right? 42:14 Although these ideas are old, right, and I update them for a modern audience, there are some things that are new, and they involve technology. I, I talk about what I call persuasion factories, right? 42:23 So there are companies that- Let's say that you wanna convince, Dan, everybody that, um, that they, they should vote for me for the Senate, okay? 'Cause I'm a great guy. 42:34 So what you do is you hire one of these companies, they employ hundreds if not thousands of micro-influencers, right? You give them, like, the massive rec- you know, let's call it the, the basic recipe, right? 42:47 And then they're told, "Here's... You can customize this or you can't. Now take it and start spreading it on your social media followers," right? So you have 1,500 micro-persuaders, right, do- doing the work of... 43:00 that used to be done by one macro-persuader. 43:03 So now, uh, w- we, we have this, this, m- these mechanisms, right, that you can take these messages and it, it's, it really is dividing them, right, into these smaller engines that deliver these formulations to people. 43:21 Uh, now they think it's coming from the influencer, quote unquote, but it isn't. 43:24 The influencer, th- there are exchange platforms where the influencers go, somebody puts a project on and what they're willing to pay, and then the influencer says, "Great, I'll take it," right? 43:33 "I, I will deliver 200 subscriptions to a magazine or 500, you know, donations to, or to a political campaign." So there is this new thing of, like, this in- I call it se- in- persuasion industrialization, right? 43:47 That you have. And there are examples in an- in antiquity, right? [laughs] Believe it or not. 43:51 But what can be done today because of technology, and it's done sort of behind the scenes, uh, that is something that's kind of new. 44:00 The other thing that's worth noting, I talk about it in the book, is that up to now, right, uh, video has had a primacy in terms of media, right? 44:09 We bo- we've tended to think that when we see something, that, that has had very high persuasive force. 44:17 Um, because of the rise of deep fakes, and now we're about to, we're about to enter the, an age where video will lose its primacy as the persuasive medium, 44:29 and, um, a- and, and how that will sort of affect how we see things remains to be seen. 44:35 I think it's a very interesting phenomena that the age of video as the dominant technical format for persuasion, uh, is coming to a close now. 44:44 So Carlos, the, uh, the book is available on presale right now on Amazon and Barnes & Noble. Yes. 44:50 But, uh, you know, e- even better than that, um, you've been kind enough to offer a, a sort of exclusive master class for, for anybody watching this and, and all of our, our members worldwide. Th- that's correct. 45:04 The, a- as I mentioned earlier, right, the, the, the origin of the book is a, a, a, a process that I, I've taken executives through, um, in, in the past, understand sort of the rules and then think about how to apply them in their own, uh, professional settings. 45:19 And so we have a, a small master class that's, uh, that will be offered, uh, I, I think we said, we said June, right, Dan? 45:27 And, and this is a, a, say, an executive level class for anyone who really wants to go deep into the content of the book a- and to... 45:37 and basically goes through the same process that I've gone through with senior executives that I've coached in the past, and it's available to our members. Yeah. Great. Thank you. 45:45 I, I think, I think, you know, you know, reading a book is, is, um, always good, uh, but, but being able to interact with you and interact with others and, and, and play out real world, you know, situations is, is invaluable. 45:59 So, uh, looking forward to, to that. If you're watching this and, and you want to, uh, join, go to network.urpaai.com and you'll see a, a professional development section there that we've added. 46:11 Uh, you can sign up or apply to sign up, uh, there. We only have room for 15, uh, folks, so, uh, please go ahead and, and, and do that a- as soon as possible. 46:20 And as Carlos mentions, uh, it'll be weekly, uh, sessions, uh, throughout, uh, throughout June. But Carlos, thanks for, uh, thanks for taking us through this and, uh- Sure... 46:31 I look forward to going back to our normal format next week, but this is, this is very, very relevant. I know, um, you know, initially I said, "Hey, how does this apply to, to my world and my life?" 46:42 And the, and the more I've talked to you about this, the more I realize this should be part of every, I think, curriculum, certainly business curriculum out there. 46:50 Well, Dan, listen, thanks for the chance to talk about the book. 46:52 It's f- it's a great topic, it's a fun class because most of the examples we look at are from movies, so, which I think are the, are the best way to make this, you know, the, illustrate these points. 47:01 So thanks for the chance to talk about the book. I appreciate it and, uh, I will see you back next week. Now regular programming will resume next Wednesday. Thanks, Dan. Yeah. Sounds good, everybody. 47:10 It's g- take care everybody. Check out the, uh, the network urpa dot, uh, network.urpaai.com for this and other new professional development training courses, master classes, uh, and other resources and groups. 47:23 Have a great week everybody. Take care. Thanks, Dan. Bye-bye. 47:25 [outro music]